Is it worse to kill than to let someone die?

Vitesse Models 1 43 Scale Diecast 713 - Ford Sierra Fina

Despite the disturbing consequences, let’s consider whether a case can be made against the idea of active harm and passive harm being inherently different from a moral standpoint. Consider the following:

Minichamps Porsche 911 Carrera Targa, Gendarmerie For 1965. Model in 1 43 scale

Scenario 1.  (Passive Murder)

1 43 Ferrari 575M FIA GT Championship 2004 Monza P.Peter F.Babini

Scenario 2. (Active Murder)

Top Model 1 43 Scale Model Car TMC127 - Talbot Maserati Monte Carlo 1956

1 43 Panoz Esperante GTR-1 Le Mans 24 Hrs 1997 DAMS

1 26 Range Rover Fire 1994 Red BAA Fire Service Kit

If you believe that active harm is inherently better than passive harm, then you must therefore conclude that walking away in Scenario 1 is superior ethically to walking away in Scenario 2. Is this something you are truly willing to accept? In both cases walking away will mean the man will die, and preventing his death is equally easy in both cases. Can we really conclude that the initial motion of the pendulum is sufficient to change the ethical characteristics of the problem?

Posted in Ethics, Philosophy | 2 Comments
Brabham Ford BT 49 C No. 6 H.Rebaque Formula 1 1981

Top Model TMC216 Ferrari 250 GT 1957 Nassau 43

Ferrari 225 S Accident Giro Di Sicilia 1953 Masetti-Cappi 1 43 Art ART098 M

Minichamps Porsche 911 (993) Coupe, Model Year 1993, In orange Met, 1 43 Scale.

Vitesse 1 43 Scale L128 Chevrolet Corvette NART 1972 Heinz Johnson

While I have met a great many non-believers and self proclaimed atheists, I have never heard anyone claim that they could absolutely disprove the existence of all possible forms of God. In fact, using some definitions of “God” (such as an unspecified “higher power”) God cannot be disproven even in theory. Furthermore, an all powerful God, if He existed, could simply make us 100% certain in His absence while he continues to exist, showing that we can never eliminate ALL possibility of such a being.

Ixo 1 43 Scale - LMC050 Rondeau M379 nd Le Mans 1981 Diecast Model Car

Posted in God, Religion, Lorenzi LO0209; Porsche 908 2; 1969 Targa Florio; RN274; Excellent Boxed, Truth | 8 Comments
Art Model 1 43 Scale ART018 - Ferrari 500 TRC Monza 1960 - Peduzzi

How to REALLY Answer a Question: Designing a Study from Scratch

Minichamps 1 43 Scale Model Car WAP 020 138 17 - Porsche 911 GT3 Cup

1 43 Ford AU Falcon - GSR Ford Credit (G.Seton) 2002 Classic Carlectables 200

Lancia Beta Montecarlo Pergusa 1979 Patrese Be9171 1 43 Model Car Diecast

Ferrari 308 Gtb Gr.4 Monza 1979 Pinto Penariol 1 43 Be9341 Model Diecast

Unfortunately, just examining how you feel after taking aspirin a single time won’t be adequate, since the aspirin may be more helpful some times and less helpful others. For example, it could be the case that it works on moderate headaches but not on severe ones, so if your next headache happened to be really severe, it would look like aspirin was useless. To solve this problem, and give yourself more data, you might resolve to make these records of how you’re feeling for each of the next 20 headaches you get.

HM Hobbymaster 1 72 Horch 1a with 20 mm flak38 HG4501

Your analyses would be a lot simpler if you scored how unpleasant each headache was on a simple scale from 1 to 5 (1 meaning slight unpleasantness, 3, moderate unpleasantness, and 5, extreme unpleasantness). That way, you can simply look at all the scores you got just before taking aspirin and average them together. You can then compare this to the average of the scores 30 minutes after taking the aspirin and 60 minutes after taking it. That way, you can see if the amount of unpleasantness you feel really does drop substantially after taking aspirin.

Panzerkampf 1 72 Russian T-14 Armata Main Battle Tank (Desert Camo) - PAN12166PB

PT-76B 336th Guards Naval Infantry Brigade Russia 1993 1 72 MODEL TANK IXO

HOBBY MASTER HG1610 1 48 US Willys Jeep 39R Wing 400 Sqdn RCAF Denmark July 1945

UPGRADE SET FOR USS MISSOURI KIT Trumpeter 1 200 TR06631 Model

Fortunately, these problems are easily remedied. Instead of giving half the group nothing, you instead give them pills in an aspirin bottle that look just like aspirin, but which have no effect on headaches. Sugar pills are a reasonable choice, because a small amount of sugar is unlikely to effect a person’s headaches.


RUSSIAN NBC LATE KIT Trumpeter 1 35 TR05516 Model

Corgi World War II Heroes Sherman Tank


But, if the results fluctuate randomly, that implies that sometimes, just by luck alone, the aspirin might seem to be effective even if it isn’t. Likewise, it might, through bad luck, seem to be ineffective, even though it does work. So whatever your experiment shows, how can you be sure you’re getting the right answer?

1 72 World War II Soviet T34 85 tank Tank Modern Tank of world

Panzerstahl Exclusive 1 72 Flakpanther D - s.Pz.Jg.Abt. 653 89001

Posted in Science, Truth | Leave a comment